Lived Experience
This is a first-person piece. Kaylyn shares her own ARFID setback and the steps that helped her through it. It isn’t medical advice, and if eating has become very hard, please reach out to a healthcare provider.
Written by Kaylyn Gray, NDI’s designer and creator of the free ARFID Self-Advocacy Workbook; co-creator of The Overexcitabilities Workbook. Reviewed by Dr. Megan Anna Neff.

I’m Kaylyn, the designer here at Neurodivergent Insights, and an AuDHDer who’s lived with ARFID my entire life (and experiences all three presentations).
Recently, I realized I was experiencing a setback with my ARFID. I knew I wasn’t eating enough, but my executive function and emotional regulation were getting harder to manage, too. I was struggling to think, let alone communicate, and I worried I was heading back to a time when I was dangerously malnourished.
Table of Contents
When Eating Gets Hard
I knew I needed to ask for help. The problem? I didn’t know what to ask for. I wanted my loved ones to know what was happening and how they could help, but I didn’t have the answers myself.
One night, during a moment of relative clarity, I realized I needed to figure out what I needed while I still had the capacity to do so. I wrote in my journal, and was able to see the priorities:
- Understand what was happening.
- Turn down the shame and “loud brain.”
- Figure out what was making eating harder and what might help.
- Find ways to communicate what I was experiencing and what I needed.
- Ask for that help or support.
Those late-night notes eventually grew into a whole workbook to help me through future setbacks, which I later developed with the NDI team. We’re sharing it for free in the hope that it might help others, too.
Understanding What’s Happening
There is sometimes a clear trigger for an ARFID setback, but sometimes it’s a bunch of smaller things piling up until there just isn’t much capacity left for eating. I knew the first thing I had to do was gather information to see which factors were at play right now, and how they were impacting me.
First, I wrote out alllll of my physical symptoms: migraines, fatigue, poor emotional regulation and executive function, unintended weight loss, weakness, dizziness, nausea, short-term memory gaps, feeling cold, increased thirst, insomnia… the list went on.
I needed to see the full picture on paper so I could gauge the severity of my symptoms, better communicate with my healthcare providers, and figure out what level of support or care I needed.
Next, I looked at what was making eating difficult. ARFID is commonly categorized as three presentations. I started by thinking about each of these areas:
Low interest in food or eating: my safe foods were not appealing anymore.
Fear of consequences (such as choking or vomiting): I was afraid of vomiting if I forced myself to eat.
Sensory sensitivities: familiar textures were suddenly feeling intolerable.
I felt totally stuck.
Then came the behavioral signs – the things I was doing when I knew I wasn’t eating enough. This one took a bit more reflection, but I knew it was necessary to confront. Some were directly related to food; others were less obvious signs that something was off. For example, I was staying quiet about my struggles and waiting until my spouse noticed. I leaned heavily into my comfort media (watching the masterpiece Theater Camp probably 80+ times that month). I was more irritable and emotionally overwhelmed, and finally “broke” when I was crying over a pan of eggs I was cooking that I knew I wasn’t going to be able to eat.
I was also wearing baggier clothes to hide my weight loss since my regular clothes weren’t fitting. And I wouldn’t let myself enjoy doing the crafts that usually soothe my soul because I felt like I didn’t deserve to do things that made me happy when I wasn’t eating enough.
Finally, I stepped back to zoom out and see what else was going on. Was this setback situational, cyclical, or both? (There’s more on this in the workbook.) I realized that complex trauma, and a whole boat-load of stress were all at play.
To put it simply, my nervous system was saying:
“Umm, why would I eat when I am surviving all these other things right now?! I’m kinda busy!”
Recognizing these patterns helped me name what was happening and understand how much they were affecting my ability to eat.
Noticing the Shame
Once I had a better idea of what was happening, it was time to address the “loud brain” that was adding some intense pressure to an already difficult situation.
ARFID can come with a lot of shame. It’s easy to get caught in an avoidance loop: struggling to eat leads to shame, shame leads to more avoidance, and suddenly, you’re not just dealing with ARFID but also all of the messages floating around in your brain on top of it.
Some of those messages can be really convincing. When shame stories take over and make it hard to think about anything else, I call that “loud brain.” And when loud brain is in control, eating can feel even harder and less accessible.
I knew the next thing I needed to do was identify the messages rolling around in my noggin’ and come up with some antidotes so I could mentally kick over those hurdles (because let’s be real, I’m not jumping a hurdle) and clear the path to some dang food.
Some of my shame stories sounded like:
“You’re being too picky/difficult… just eat!”
“That’s not healthy enough” or “That doesn’t have enough protein.”
“This was a safe food yesterday. Why can’t I just eat it today?!”
These messages often boiled down to something like: I’m having difficulty eating, so something must be wrong with me. I’m broken.
To figure out where those thoughts were coming from, I drew a line down a piece of paper. On one side, I wrote what was actually happening. On the other, I wrote what my brain was telling me it meant.
What was happening: I had no appetite.
What my brain said: “I’m broken.”
What was happening: I was struggling to eat.
What my brain said: “I’m burdening my loved ones and letting them down.”
What was happening: I was losing weight.
What my brain said: “I’m failing and losing all of my progress.”
It…. wasn’t fun. But putting those thoughts on paper helped me see how my brain was taking the facts and twisting them into something much more dramatic that did a number on my self-worth. My brain just loves to hold onto those thoughts and throw them back in my face.
Reducing the Shame
So, how do we turn these shame stories around?
The goal isn’t to throw toxic positivity at yourself. It’s to find things that genuinely help turn down the volume on loud brain so you can redirect some of that energy toward eating and recovery.
Here were a few reminders that helped me:
“A meal is not a moral event. It is safe for me to eat food – any food.”
“Right now, adequate and tolerable matters more than perfect.”
“My current difficulties don’t erase my previous progress.”
I also revisited my “what my brain is saying” list and practiced reframing those thoughts:
- “I’m broken” ➡️ “My ability to eat is impaired right now.”
- “I’m burdening my loved ones and letting them down.” ➡️ “This is exactly what support is for.”
- “I’m failing and losing all of my progress.” ➡️ “Something has changed, and I need support.”
These reframes gave me something to respond with when the overwhelming thoughts came up. But some days, loud brain took over so completely that I simply couldn’t believe any of them. I felt like a complete failure of a human.
On those days, I needed a stronger antidote. I needed my good evidence bank.
My good evidence bank is a collection of reminders I can return to when my loud brain is in control. Here are a few of mine:
- “I am struggling, but I am still here.”
- “I am not starting from the bottom. I have years of evidence that I have survived this before (intentionally or not) and that I can nourish myself. The fact this is happening does not erase that.”
- “I found the seasonal trauma patterns this time, and that is going to help me prepare better for this time next year.”
- “I reached out for help instead of keeping everything to myself.”
- “I am doing the best I can with the capacity I have today.”
Your evidence bank should be personal to you. Anything that’s true, supportive, and uniquely useful to you is valid. The point isn’t to convince yourself everything is fine – ARFID sucks. The point is to find reminders that feel believable enough to help you stay grounded.
And when none of that is working, I turn to one activity that’s so effective it makes me dislike it. 😂
Try this
Think about someone you deeply care about and want the best for. It could be someone in your life, someone you don’t personally know, or even a fictional character.
Now imagine this person is struggling in the same ways you are. Maybe they’re experiencing an ARFID flare, losing weight, feeling exhausted or depressed, or struggling to eat despite desperately wanting to.
What would you say to them? What would you want them to know? How would you reassure them, encourage them, or remind them they’re worthy of care (even while they’re struggling)?
What would it look like to offer yourself that same compassion?
(Gut punch, right?! But it works!)
Identifying Barriers
During this setback, sweets weren’t tolerable for the first time in my life. In fact, anything sugary was making me nauseous. And let me tell you – that was WEIRD for me.
Usually, something sweet can motivate me to eat something more nutritious first. But what felt like overnight, the only thing I craved was salad.
I kept thinking, “This is SO strange! It’s like Lorelai Gilmore waking up and not wanting coffee, and only craving herbal tea!” But I couldn’t get the thought of fresh salad out of my head.
The only problem was that making salad at home is really hard for me. I tend to inspect every little thing that goes into the bowl for contaminated or “unworthy” pieces. (Produce tends to have that effect on me when I’m preparing any food at home.)
I also have to eat gluten-free for medical reasons, and I’ve been a vegetarian most of my life because I can’t tolerate the taste or texture of meat. So, as I tried to figure out what sounded tolerable, my only solution was ordering takeout salad from one of two places in my small town.
This helped me identify a few important questions:
I started writing out what sounded possible, what made eating easier, and what made it harder.
You don’t need to know exactly what you need before asking for help. But taking some time to identify your barriers and potential supports can make it easier to explain what’s going on and figure out what comes next.
I started by listing my non-negotiables and important needs: the things that had to be considered when figuring out what might work (or not work). For me, that meant eating gluten-free and vegetarian, while also accounting for the sensory aversions to common meat alternatives like tofu, soy, eggplant, and mushrooms.
I also identified what I know doesn’t work for me. This included things I’d tried that made eating harder, increased negative emotions, or added more barriers instead of reducing them. Examples included force-feeding, meal-prepping, detailed meal plans, nutrition-first planning, food journals, and family responses that triggered shame.
Next, I considered what might reduce friction, pressure, and that pesky shame. I thought about anything that could make eating even 5% more possible, less overwhelming, less lonely, or less exhausting.
My Autistic brain loves to categorize, so I did just that and categorized them into these areas:
- Food-related support: Takeout, leftovers, visible and accessible food, frozen meals, someone else cooking, or permission to eat whatever sounded tolerable without worrying about variety or “healthy” eating.
- Executive function support: Help scheduling appointments, grocery shopping, making decisions, doing dishes, or reminders to eat.
- Nervous system and capacity support: Someone sitting with me – or giving me space – while I ate, gentle reminders without pressure, the comfort of my pet, or watching something comforting while eating.
- Sensory support: Non-metal utensils, deciding what to eat based on what texture sounded tolerable, reducing background noise and strong smells, adjusting the lighting, or wearing comfortable clothes.
- Emotional support: Talking through emotions, learning more about ARFID, asking people around me to avoid food-related judgment, or working with a trusted dietitian, therapist, or other healthcare provider.
The next thing I did was sort my ideas into three categories: what I could do myself, what would be easier with support, and what I needed someone else to help me with. For example:
What I can do myself
Set an alarm so I don’t forget to eat, have the same meal for breakfast every day, and put on a favorite TV show while eating.
What would be easier with support
Have my spouse come to my doctor’s appointment, get help with grocery planning & shopping, and process my emotions to identify triggers.
What I need someone else’s help with
Scheduling my next appointment (because phone calls are the WORST), asking for space while I ate, and asking for financial help so I can order 1-2 takeout meals a week.
From there, I had to figure out who I could ask for each kind of support. My spouse could come to appointments, my mom could potentially help financially, and my best friend who lives far away could give me gentle reminders to eat.
If you’re thinking, “I don’t really have anyone I can ask,” that doesn’t mean you’re doing anything wrong. Not everyone has a supportive family, partner, friend group, or safe person close to them. Some people have loved ones who don’t understand ARFID or see their needs as valid. Others have support that is limited, complicated, changing, or just unavailable right now.
Your needs are still valid. Support doesn’t have to come from one person, or even from someone you know personally. Depending on your circumstances, support might come from a healthcare provider, therapist, dietitian, support group, online community, school, workplace, community organization, or another service. But I just want you to know that you are not alone in this struggle.
Asking for Help
When we’re at low capacity, it can feel impossible to communicate what’s helpful and what isn’t. Especially when we’re already hearing unsupportive or invalidating comments, sometimes we just want to inject “what not to say” and “what to say” directly into people’s brains so they can just KNOW.
Sometimes the people who care about us genuinely want to help but aren’t sure how. They might offer advice, encouragement, or solutions that come from a good place but end up adding to our shame or making eating harder. Their intentions may be good, but the result is still a miss.
To help with this, I literally wrote it out. Here are some examples of what’s supportive to me, and what’s not.
Helpful
- “What sounds possible right now?”
- “Would you like help getting food?”
- “Would it help if I made the decision for you?”
- “Would you like me to list out some options?”
- “I am not judging you – you can eat whatever you need to feel safe.”
Unhelpful
- “Just eat! You’re being too picky.”
- “But you liked this yesterday.”
- “You need more protein.”
- Sneaking things into my food
- Making it a big deal if I do eat, or shaming me if I don’t
The free workbook includes more examples, plus a template you can fill out and share with a loved one. Communicating these things is HARD, so I wanted to make it a little easier for both you and me (because I’m SURE I’ll need to refer to this again in the future, haha).
Another important part of asking for help is actually initiating the conversation. Admitting that you need help out loud can be one of the hardest parts, especially when you’re exhausted or overwhelmed.
But you don’t need a complete plan before reaching out. You can simply ask someone to help you figure out what comes next.
The goal is to communicate something while you still have access to the words.
Here’s a starting point you can adapt to your situation:
What I’ve noticed:
“Lately, I’ve noticed I….”
What I’m worried about:
“I’m concerned that….”
What would help:
“Could you help me with…?”
What doesn’t help:
“It makes things harder when…”
Warning signs:
“One sign that I’m struggling is…. If you notice this, please…”
My next step:
“My goal is to…”
How you can support me:
“I would like to ask if you can…”
You don’t have to fill in every blank to explain everything perfectly. Even one sentence can be a starting point.
Conclusion
I’m happy to report that I was able to get back to my normal and much healthier level of “eating is still difficult sometimes, but I’m eating!” My hope is that what came from me working through this little personal hell due to this most recent ARFID setback can help someone else who struggles with this, too.
I hope the free workbook helps you identify what’s going on, find language for your experience, or feel a little more able to ask for help. And if something in this article made you feel less alone, I’m a happy camper because you are definitely not alone in the struggle.
You’re allowed to have needs and ask for support. You don’t have to do everything at once or have everything figured out to move forward. Eating and recovery happen one step at a time, and you don’t have to navigate them alone.
To quote my wonderful co-worker, Nick: “ARFID sucks, you don’t.”
You got this. Keep going.
💙 Your ARFID Friend
ARFID Setback FAQs
What is an ARFID setback?
An ARFID setback is a stretch of time when eating gets harder again after it had felt more manageable. Sometimes there is a clear trigger. Other times, smaller stressors pile up until there isn’t much capacity left for eating. Signs can show up in the body (fatigue, nausea, weight loss), in behavior (hiding struggles, leaning on comfort media), and in a louder, more shame-filled inner voice.
What are the three presentations of ARFID?
ARFID is commonly grouped into three presentations: low interest in food or eating, fear of consequences such as choking or vomiting, and sensory sensitivities to things like taste, texture, or smell. Many people experience more than one, and which one is loudest can change during a setback.
How do you ask for help during an ARFID setback?
You don’t need a complete plan before reaching out. Start with one sentence about what you’ve noticed, what you’re worried about, or what would help. It can also help to sort your needs into what you can do yourself, what would be easier with support, and what you need someone else to do.
What should you not say to someone with ARFID?
Comments like “just eat,” “you liked this yesterday,” or “you need more protein” tend to add shame and make eating harder. Sneaking food into meals or making a big deal about whether someone ate can backfire too. Questions like “What sounds possible right now?” or “Would you like help getting food?” are usually kinder places to start.
Free Workbook
Navigating an ARFID setback can feel overwhelming, especially when you don’t know what you need or how to ask for help. The ARFID Self-Advocacy Workbook is free and lived-experience-informed, with gentle prompts and practical templates to help you understand what’s happening, reduce shame, identify barriers, and communicate your support needs.
Additional Resources
The ARFID Self-Advocacy Workbook: Kaylyn’s free workbook, with prompts and templates for understanding a setback, easing shame, and asking for support.
Anorexia vs. ARFID: Understanding the differences between these two eating disorders, including the three types of ARFID.
Free Resources: Browse NDI’s free resources for neurodivergent adults, including guides and worksheets.
More from Kaylyn: The Overexcitabilities Workbook, which Kaylyn co-created, explores intense ways of feeling and sensing and how to care for yourself within them.
Stay in the Neurodivergent Loop
For ongoing insights and updates, subscribe to the Neurodivergent Insights Newsletter. Each Sunday, we send out fresh thoughts and a roundup of the newest resources on topics related to neurodivergence, mental health, and wellness. My most personal writing is reserved for my newsletter, and subscribers also get access to the newsletter vault (12+ PDFs) when they join.



